Movie: Inglourious Basterds
Inglourious Basterds is another revenge film by Quentin Tarantino. Unlike the Kill Bill films though, the message of this movie is much more nuanced.
In Kill Bill, no matter how graphic the violence became, I think we all knew who the hero was. Even if we didn’t agree with her decided path, we knew whom we wanted to win in the fights.
For Inglourious Basterds, Tarantino has a band of Jewish-American soldiers and the lone survivor of a massacred Jewish family separately going up against Nazis. The heroes should be clear no?
But the revenge fantasy is not so simple. The Americans are not that admirable. Their guerilla, or terrorist, tactics involve the graphic violence we’ve come to expect from Taratino, but the visuals are somewhat more unsettling here.
They hit more like the Michael Madsen ear scene from Reservoir Dogs. I almost couldn’t help but censor the “heroes” and sympathize with the “villains” during them.
It may be because the Basterds is essentially a unit made up of that Madsen character.
Interestingly, Taratino has the revenge seekers use methods and tactics that we, good film goers, have already condemned as seen in other recent movies because there, the brutality was exacted upon Americans, American soldiers, or another sympathetic surrogates.
As the Nazis continue to get their comeuppance in this movie, I couldn’t help but be put off while not completely being able to disagree with the actions of the Allies.
The pen is mightier than the sword. Or, since we don’t read and write as much as we used to, perhaps movies are mightier than the sword.
Perhaps Quentin Taratino is showing that fiction (stories) and history (the storytelling of actual events) are the most powerful mechanisms of revenge. By setting this revenge fantasy within historical contexts, we can really evaluate the worth of revenge and brutality. That which sound great in our minds will be disastrous if we ever let them lose upon reality.
History and art are going to tell our stories. The heroes and villains among us may do well to consider that.
If I Picked the Oscars (in order of my vote)
Best Picture:
- Avatar
- Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire
- District 9
- The Hurt Locker
- Inglourious Basterds
- Up in the Air
- Up
- An Education
- A Serious Man
- The Blind Side
Directing:
